Burton's Alice in Wonderland was recently released, sparking all sorts of renewed cynicism towards Lewis Carroll concerning his proposed drug-use and fascination with little girls. My university's Sigma Tau Delta selected the book for this semester's book club in hopes that the timing with the film would increase the audience. (Since I've offered extra credit for my 100 students, I don't think attendance will be a problem.) They asked myself and another professor to be the primary speakers and host a panel where students may ask us questions about the book.
After spending the last two weeks (in what I could call "spare" time, though I'm not sure what that phrase means) reading Alice again, Carroll's biography, books on Alice, etc., I finally wrote a paper. The contents were unexpected to me, and I know they'll be surprising to my audience this evening. I found myself relying on G.K. Chesterton's Orthodoxy to understand the profound importance of this nonsense work. Who'd 've thunk orthodoxy would go well with nonsense?
What I discovered is that Alice's adventures accomplish what Chesterton asserts all people need: a foot in fairyland. Chesterton believes this foot away from earth stabilizes; its madness keeps us sane. Wonderland not only reveals our ridiculous emphasis on reason by parodying it, but paradoxically its nonsense also counters our dependence on reason.
Chesterton writes in Lunacy and Letters, "Carroll's works should be read by sages and gray-haired philosophers in order to study the darkest problems of metaphysics, the borderland between reason and unreason, and the nature of the most erratice of spiritual forces, humor, which eternally dances between the two." He meant this appraisal of Carroll's works.
In Wonderland, Alice is questioned about who she is and where she is going and where she wants to go, and she has no answers. Because she does not know who she is, she does not know where to go. The implications are intriguing. Tonight, I hope not to explain Alice, but to draw out these implications. I hope that by reminding students how to wonder about these questions, they'll find the answers. Perhaps, like Alice, they'll leave the lecture saying, "It's no use going back to the beginning, for I was a different person then."